Announcement

Collapse

Announcement

~ gang gang ~
See more
See less

is Yellowstone good or bad?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • is Yellowstone good or bad?

    because i absolutely 100% cannot stop watching it.

  • #2
    ok never mind. like dont get me wrong im sure ill plow through the rest of it but at its heart its really just kevin costner singing a lullaby to a completely bullshit macho fantasy about the nobility of america's ranchcore. its actually pretty nauseating. think 'succession' but with cowboys and punisher tattoos.

    Comment


    • #3
      Come on man it's an amazing show....

      Comment


      • #4
        Originally posted by Tyde View Post
        Come on man it's an amazing show....
        ill say this much, season 4 is about a thousand times better than season 3 but at some point we have to shake off the nuances and admit that its absolutely boomerporn. like as of the last few episodes the livestock officers are an actual honest to god paramilitary death squad. i mean honestly yikes.

        also im sorry but kevin costners whole vibe is hank hill imagining himself as clint eastwood in a fever dream.

        Comment


        • #5
          there is absolutely No Fucking Way this doesnt end up in next seasons plotline:

          https://nypost.com/2021/11/20/billio...-sex-partners/

          Comment


          • OVENWAX
            OVENWAX commented
            Editing a comment
            this deserves its own thread

        • #6
          ok they definitely rejiggered their writers because im actually really enjoying this season so far. splintering jimmy off into texas was honestly brilliant and i hope we get to see a lot more of him honestly.

          Comment


          • #7
            Originally posted by sonatine View Post
            there is absolutely No Fucking Way this doesnt end up in next seasons plotline:

            https://nypost.com/2021/11/20/billio...-sex-partners/
            hof article, my favorite line got to be

            Bryan Nash was a former workout buddy from California, who had reluctantly accompanied Goguen to bars and strip clubs
            when i got to bars and strip clubs i go reluctantly lmao

            Comment


            • sonatine
              sonatine commented
              Editing a comment
              definitely going to be hearing more about all these cats. looking forward to the inevitable scorcese / decaprio / deniro project about them.

          • #8
            absolutely incredible.

            https://www.gawker.com/culture/how-t...s-thanksgiving

            Comment


            • #9
              • If you think about it, Yellowstone and Succession are basically the same show except Yellowstone has more guns and Succession has more jokes. But, ya know, same set up. Jamie is Shiv, Beth is Kendall, Kayce is Roman, and obviously John is Logan.
              i feel so fucking seen right now.

              Comment


              • #10
                Tyde excuse me what episode does beth fuck her dad in, any guesses?

                Comment


                • #11
                  you know.... at its best, this show is a cormac mccarthy novel. the texas narrative is knocking it out of the park, there hasnt been a single moment that isnt compelling since jimmy got dropped off there.

                  and at its worst, its just the basest, dumbest, most lazy boomer porn. and in the middle its a shitty soap opera. the shit with jamie and his biological dad is agonizingly stupid. in fact every single time jamie is on screen, the show pretty much blasts its own nuts off by throwing the pin instead of the grenade. and the only reason beth doesnt share the top step on the reward podium is because she doesnt actually have any plot line at all so far.

                  Comment


                  • #12
                    ok one other thing that really bugs the shit out of me with this show is they constantly show people getting in fist fights and seem to have absolutely no idea how much damage actually happens during a fist fight. like broken ribs, hands, jaws, eye sockets, teeth, these start to get racked up pretty fast, but on this show two grown ass men with established histories of violence will beat the shit out of each other for like over an hour and then dust themselves off because they have to work the next day after all.

                    its honestly distracting.

                    half the people on this show would be drooling gimps by the end of last season in real life.

                    Comment


                    • #13
                      the whole jamie / dads plot was so bizarre and senseless and superfluous and arbitrary. where the hell was the wife and infant when jamie blew his dads brains out? what did jamie do about the copious amounts of blood and brains that would have been generated? why is dumb bitch beth taking incriminating photographs when like one scene before, her incredibly powerful ex boss is swearing shes going to start gathering digital evidence to prosecute beth?

                      if the writing was just like 5-10% better this show could be absolutely legendary.

                      Comment


                      • #14
                        I got stuck around s3. First two seasons were ok. Likely finish it at some point.

                        Comment


                        • #15
                          i feel like this show is going to go full Dallas and shock reveal that the alcoholic sterilized daughter is adopted too.

                          Comment


                          • gimmick
                            gimmick commented
                            Editing a comment
                            Was Dallas the one where half a season was a coma dream?

                          • sonatine
                            sonatine commented
                            Editing a comment
                            *pursing lips and nodding*
                        Working...
                        X